Judge Grants CoStar's Motion in Ongoing Legal Battle Against Realtor.com Parent

July 31, 2024
Share this Post: 

The legal battle between CoStar Group and portal rival Move Inc. (parent of Realtor.com) continues as a court in Los Angeles yesterday granted CoStar's motion for expedited discovery in the case related to James Kaminsky, the former Realtor.com employee who now works for CoStar.

The ruling handed down by Judge George H. Wu essentially means that both sides must exchange information related to the case. In requesting the discovery motion CoStar was keen for Move to reveal the exact nature of its complaint against Kaminsky and how the ex-Realtor.com Editor's actions allegedly damaged its business.

The legal spat between the two portal rivals began earlier this month when Move filed a lawsuit against CoStar claiming that its former News & Insights Editor James Kaminsky "stole confidential business information" and "established surreptitious, undetected ongoing access to allow himself (and thus CoStar) to spy on Move's highly confidential documents."

Since then Move has filed for a preliminary injunction—essentially an attempt to have the court block "any further unauthorized access" to the documents at the centre of the case—and CoStar has put Kaminsky on administrative leave "out of an abundance of caution".

Kaminsky has also released a statement via his lawyers explaining his actions as having been motivated by privacy concerns and a desire to help himself in his job search after being laid off by Move in January 2024.

“Before leaving Move and ultimately returning my laptop computer to Move, I did not have time to carefully prune the selection of emails that I wanted to delete for personal privacy purposes, so I erased the majority of my emails and electronic files to prevent them from being seen by the technology personnel who would be processing my computer return.”

“I had no interest in saving these documents, sharing these documents, or using those documents for any reason beyond short term help in generating job hunting materials for myself. I gave myself what I assumed would be temporary access to them in the most transparent and public way I know: literally putting my name on them.”

CoStar's CEO, Andy Florance backed his employee in comments made on stage at the Inman Connect real estate agent event yesterday in Las Vegas saying that his firm would not let Kaminsky "be the fall guy" for Move's legal action which he called "a PR stunt".

A deadline for the parties sharing the discovery information has been set for August 5th with Move's motion for a preliminary injunction set for September 23rd.

 

CoStar's lawyers will also be paying close attention to court proceedings on the other side of the country as Matterport—the subject of a $1.6 billion acquisition bid from CoStar—appealed a Delaware court ruling granting its former CEO the right to claim $79 million.

The issue relates to company by-laws that Matterport introduced before going public in 2021 that restricted shareholders from selling stock as the company stabilized. Brown challenged these bylaws in a 2022 lawsuit, arguing that his shares were excluded from the lockup period and was right to do so in the opinion of the Judge.

In May a judge ruled that Brown was entitled to compensation from Matterport but not the $141 million he had originally sued for.

The digital twin specialist filed the appeal on Tuesday a few days after its shareholders voted overwhelmingly in favour of accepting CoStar's bid.

CoStar has not commented directly on the court proceedings but there is a possibility that if Matterport's appeal is unsuccessful the acquisition deal could run into difficulty.

July 31, 2024
Since March 2020 Edmund's job has been to read about, write about, collect data on, analyse and generally know about real estate marketplaces and the companies that run them. Before that he worked at the aggregator Mitula Group (which became Lifull Connect) for five years.

Subscribe to our mailing list to get the famous, free Friday newsletter!

News and analysis to help build better online marketplace businesses, in your inbox, every Friday

Related News

Untitled Design 12
Adevinta Breakup Incoming in Spain? Yes, Internal Sources Tell Spanish Newspaper

Rumours of a big Adevinta breakup have gained further momentum with El Nacional reporting that new owners Permira and Blackstone...

Read More
Realtor.com Building 1
News Corp Q1 2025: Move Inc Records 2% Revenue Drop Amid Depressed Market Conditions

Realtor.com owner Move Inc. saw revenues dip slightly according to parent company News Corp's Q1 financial statement for the 2025...

Read More
Olx Brazil Boardroom 2
OLX Brazil's Horizontal Marketplace to Charge Buyers, Not Sellers, In Pricing Shakeup

OLX-Brazil has shifted fees from sellers to buyers for transactions closed on its marketplace after enacting a major pricing strategy...

Read More
Untitled Design 17 3
REA group Q1 2025: Revenues of A$413m, up 21% YoY, In Strong Start for Australian Giant

REA Group, the ASX-listed, Murdoch-backed marketplace giant, has released typically strong financial results for the first quarter of Australia's financial...

Read More

Editor's Pick